New seasonal limited release cookie!

Key lime pie in cookie form! A soft and chewy key lime cookie made with real key lime zest, creamy white chocolate chips, and graham cracker pieces, topped with a tangy key lime glaze and finished with graham cracker crumbs.

These cookies are only available for a limited time this summer while fresh key lime supplies last.

Brown butter cookie loaded with buttery toffee bits and finished with flaky sea salt. Crisp edges, chewy center, rich caramelized flavor in every bite.

Larger cookies are around 2.5oz. Smaller cookies are around 1.6oz.

Chewy oatmeal cookies loaded with butterscotch chips, kissed with cinnamon and vanilla. Cozy, nostalgic, and deeply satisfying.

Cookies are around 2.5oz.

A chocolate chip cookie meets a campfire classic. Graham cracker crumbs baked right into the dough, mini marshmallows throughout, and a golden toasted marshmallow on top. S’more of everything you love.

Smaller cookies: 1.6 oz
Large cookies: 2.5oz

Brown butter chocolate chip cookies with chewy centers, crisp edges, melty chocolate, and flaky sea salt. Rich, cozy, bakery-style perfection.

A bakery-style funfetti cookie with soft, chewy centers, buttery vanilla flavor, and crunchy rainbow sprinkles throughout. Fun, colorful, and perfect for celebrations of all kinds! Sprinkle colors can be changed seasonally or customized for holidays and special occasions.

Earthy matcha, creamy white chocolate, and a hint of strawberry come together in this soft and chewy brown butter cookie inspired by a strawberry matcha latte.

Can’t decide? Let me choose for you!

Our Baker’s Choice Variety Boxes are the perfect way to sample a variety of Sweet Erindipity favorites and discover a new go-to cookie. Each box is hand-selected from the flavors available that week and baked fresh to order.

Choose from:

• Signature Variety Box – Includes 6 cookies from my signature collection of customer-favorite, everyday flavors: brown butter salted toffee, s’mores, oatmeal butterscotch, and chocolate chip cookies.

• Deluxe Variety Box – Includes 4 cookies from my signature collection plus 2 specialty, seasonal, or limited-edition flavors. You may even get a sneak peek of a new recipe before it officially joins the menu!

All variety boxes are baker’s choice and based on current availability. Specific flavors cannot be guaranteed.

These Candied Pecan cookies are made with nutty browned butter and loaded with homemade candied pecans for the perfect balance of sweet crunch and chewy texture. Finished with a sprinkle of flaky sea salt, each bite is rich, buttery, and packed with toasted pecan flavor.

Whether you’re celebrating the first day of school, surprising your child, or thanking a favorite teacher, this Back to School Cookie Box is the perfect gift.

Each gift-ready box includes:
Three gourmet cookies
Baker’s Choice assortment
School-themed gift packaging with ribbon and festive sticker

Ready to gift, no wrapping required!